What really happened inside the Abt family home, and how did a trusted insider become the center of one of Pennsylvania’s most disturbing murder cases? On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD Sergeant and criminal justice professor Joseph Giacalone welcomes investigative journalist and author Kathryn Canavan to discuss her gripping true crime book, Killer in the House. Together, they examine the shocking murders of John Abt, Margaret Abt, and their son John Abt III, a case that stunned the community and raised questions about trust, betrayal, greed, and the psychology of murder. In this exclusive interview, we’ll explore: 🔹 The details of the Abt family murders 🔹 How the investigation unfolded 🔹 The evidence that led detectives to the killer 🔹 The motivations behind the crime 🔹 The challenges of reporting and writing true crime 🔹 Lessons investigators can learn from the case today If you’re fascinated by true crime investigations, family murder cases, criminal psychology, and the stories behind some of America’s most shocking homicides, this is an episode you won’t want to miss. #TrueCrime #AbtFamilyMurders #KathrynCanavan #KillerInTheHouse #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #MurderInvestigation #FamilyMurder #CrimePodcast #ColdCase #CriminalPsychology #joegiacalone #TrueCrimeAuthor #PennsylvaniaCrime #MurderCase #DetectiveStories

This week on Roll Calle, retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar joins us live to discuss the two convictions this past week, those of Karmelo Anthony and Zachariah Rasch. Two different sets of circumstancies but the same outcome. Should Karmel Anthony taken the stance in his own defense? Why did Zachariah Rasch do it? Good or bad moves? We’ll also discuss the upcoming sentencing of the Long Island Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann. What we can expect and what it means for the case. The New Hampshire Supreme Court has overturned the second degree murder charges against Adam Montgomery. If you recall, Montgomery was convicted in 2024 for the death of his 5-year-old daughter, Harmony. 00:00 Introduction and Welcome 02:15 Case Breakdown: Karmelo Anthony Trial and Legal Defense Strategy 18:40 The Zachariah Rasch Case: Analyzing Motive and Circumstances 32:10 Assessing Defendant Testimony: Good vs. Bad Courtroom Moves 44:55 Long Island Serial Killer Update: Rex Heuermann Upcoming Sentencing and Case Impact 59:20 New Hampshire Supreme Court Ruling: Overturning the Adam Montgomery Charges 1:12:15 Live Q&A and Interactive Audience Roll Call #truecrimewiththesarge #truecrimecommunity #joegiacalone #michaelalcazar #karmeloanthony #zachariahrasch #court #trialcoverage #rexheuermann #lisk #gilgobeach

The Gilgo Beach investigation continues to raise major questions, even after the arrest of alleged serial killer Rex Heuermann. In this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD Sergeant Joseph Giacalone is joined by acclaimed filmmaker and Gilgo investigator Josh Zeman for a deep dive into the mysteries that still surround one of America’s most notorious serial killer investigations. Together, they examine the biggest unanswered questions in the Gilgo Beach murders, including the evidence against Rex Heuermann, possible additional victims, unanswered timelines, investigative mistakes, and whether law enforcement has revealed the full picture to the public. Topics include: • Could there be more victims connected to Gilgo Beach? • What was in the storage facilities? • What evidence remains sealed from the public? • What about the 50 hotel keys recovered at his home? • Who left the dolls at the crime scene? • Could more arrests still happen? • What unanswered questions continue to frustrate victims’ families? And more! @SinisterPodcastJZ brings unique insight from years covering the Gilgo Beach murders, documentaries, and interviews connected to the case, while Sgt. Giacalone provides expert law enforcement analysis on the investigation and prosecution strategy. If you follow the Gilgo Beach case, Rex Heuermann updates, serial killer investigations, or true crime analysis, this is a conversation you do not want to miss. #GilgoBeach #RexHeuermann #TrueCrime #JoshZeman #SerialKiller #LongIslandSerialKiller #LISK #TrueCrimeCommunity #CrimeNews #GilgoBeachMurders #joegiacalone #truecrimewiththesarge #joegiacalone #joshzeman

Tonight on Roll Call for True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar joins me for a deep dive into some of the most talked-about true crime cases making headlines right now. We break down the case against Karmelo Anthony, who stands accused in the killing of Austin Metcalf, and examine the evidence, legal questions, and public reaction surrounding the case. We’ll also discuss the shocking acquittal of Ricky Chow and what the verdict could mean moving forward. In addition, we analyze the latest developments in the Zachariah Rasch trial and explore the disturbing discovery of Melissa Casios’ skeletonized remains, including what investigators may be looking at next. Join us LIVE as we separate facts from speculation, answer your questions, and provide expert law enforcement insight into these complex and emotional cases. 🔔 Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge for breaking true crime coverage, live analysis, expert interviews, and in-depth investigations. 0:00:02 Introduction 0:00:34 Carmelo Anthony stabbing case overview 0:01:48 The debate on cameras in the courtroom 0:03:33 Opening arguments and the tent argument 0:04:34 The danger of impulsive reactions 0:07:14 Clearing up misconceptions about Texas murder charges 0:09:16 Analysis of the surveillance video 0:12:47 Detective's story on professional security and wands 0:16:55 Racial composition of the jury 0:20:12 Testimony from the football coach 0:23:44 Ricky Chow case overview and racial tension 0:26:47 The incident: Shoplifting allegation to shooting 0:29:43 The legal argument for self-defense 0:31:30 Shoot or don't shoot: Professional perspective 0:34:56 Melissa Casillas missing person/homicide case 0:36:56 Analyzing the staged crime scene 0:39:45 Importance of proper police training 0:49:01 Wisconsin vs. Zachariah Rasch trial 0:50:00 Damning internet search history 0:54:56 Bigfoot, UFOs, and closing remarks #TrueCrime #KarmeloAnthony #AustinMetcalf #RickyChow #ZachariahRasch #MelissaCasios #MichaelAlcazar #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #CrimeNews #MurderCase #CriminalJustice #BreakingNews #LiveStream #CourtTV #CrimeAnalysis #PoliceInvestigation #Forensics #TrueCrimeCommunity #TrialCoverage #justice

Tonight on True Crime with the Sarge, acclaimed director Josh Zeman joins us LIVE for an interactive true crime Q&A covering the latest developments in the Gilgo Beach investigation, accused serial killer Rex Heuermann, and the biggest stories dominating the true crime world. Bring your questions as we dive deep into: * The prosecution’s case against Rex Heuermann * The latest Gilgo Beach evidence and unanswered questions * Behavioral analysis of alleged serial offenders * The victims and their families * Investigative mistakes and breakthroughs * Media coverage and public fascination with serial killer cases * Other major true crime headlines and audience questions LIVE Josh Zeman, known for his groundbreaking work on the Gilgo Beach murders, gives insider insight into one of America’s most disturbing and closely watched serial killer investigations. This is your chance to interact live, ask questions, and hear expert analysis from two experienced voices in true crime. Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don’t miss this live discussion on one of the most talked-about criminal cases in America. 00:00:01 Introduction and Welcome 00:00:33 New York State Elder Parole Concerns 00:02:10 Discussion on David Berkowitz and Prison Life 00:04:34 Unsolved New York City Cases 00:09:25 Unsolved US Cases 00:10:45 Career Paths Outside of True Crime 00:13:13 Neil Falls and Potential Connections 00:16:26 Rex Heuermann Truck Evidence 00:18:03 Release of Evidence Files 00:21:18 Connection to Sugar Bear aka Andre Isaacs 00:23:52 Civilian Attendance at Rex Heuermann Sentencing 00:25:36 Contents of the Storage Unit 00:27:24 Controlling the Narrative 00:29:26 Repercussions for Leaking Evidence 00:30:53 Possibility of More Confessions 00:33:37 Did Asa Know About the Storage Unit 00:35:05 Cameras in the Courtroom 00:37:19 DNA Upload to CODIS 00:40:08 Predictions for Rex Heuermann DNA Hits 00:41:39 Sandra Castella Case Details 00:43:39 Backpage and Investigative Obstacles 00:46:12 Tony K Execution Update 00:47:20 The Green Avalanche and Evidence 00:50:00 The Belt Evidence Mystery 00:51:56 Did Rex Call During The Killing Season 00:53:08 Origin of True Crime with the Sarge and Collaboration 00:56:17 Why Karen Vergata Was Pled To 00:57:19 Potential Hereditary Criminality 01:02:04 Future of the Gilgo Beach Investigation #TrueCrime #RexHeuermann #GilgoBeach #GilgoBeachMurders #JoshZeman #SerialKillers #TrueCrimeCommunity #LongIslandSerialKiller #CrimeNews #LiveStream #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #LISK #CrimeInvestigation #MissingPersons #ColdCases #joegiacalone

Welcome to Roll Call on True Crime with the Sarge! On this episode of Roll Call on True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD detective Michael Alcazar joins me for a deep dive into three of the biggest true crime stories dominating headlines right now. We break down the latest developments surrounding Alex Murdaugh and the growing legal battle over a possible re-trial. What new arguments are being raised, what could happen next in court, and could the convicted former attorney actually get another shot at freedom? We also examine the latest in the case involving Luigi Mangione, including new legal developments, public reaction, and what investigators and prosecutors may be focusing on behind the scenes. Netflix’s new documentary called Crash, which outlines the prosecution of Mackenzie Shirilla in the deaths of her boyfriend, Dominic Russo and his friend Davion Flanagan. Plus, we tackle one of the most controversial questions in modern true crime: Could accused Long Island serial killer Rex Heuermann ever become eligible for parole if convicted? We explain how parole eligibility works, what sentencing could look like, and why this case continues to captivate the nation. Join us live as we break down the evidence, legal strategy, criminal profiling, courtroom tactics, and the biggest unanswered questions in these high-profile cases. If you’re passionate about true crime, criminal investigations, serial killer cases, and expert law enforcement analysis, this is an episode you don’t want to miss. 00:02 Elder Parole and Rex Heuermann 08:38 Alex Murdaugh Re-Trial and Becky Hill Scandal 16:24 Netflix Documentary Crash Breakdown 29:58 Luigi Mangione Case Update 36:34 Mental Health and Policing 52:18 Police Story Time #AlexMurdaugh #RexHeuermann #LuigiMangione #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #RollCall #MichaelAlcazar #SerialKillers #CrimeNews #GilgoBeach #MurdaughTrial #TrueCrimeCommunity #NYPD #CriminalJustice #crimeanalysis #mackenzieshirilla #dominicrusso #mackenzie

Today on Roll Call on True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar joins me for a deep dive into three major true crime headlines shaking the country. We break down the latest legal twist involving Alex Murdaugh and the growing questions surrounding his possible new trial. Could courtroom controversy reopen one of America’s most infamous murder cases? We also examine the shocking re-sentencing of convicted NYC serial killer Harvey Marcelin after legal challenges forced the case back into court. What does this mean for victims’ families and the justice system? Plus, we discuss the decision not to remove Chris Nanos from office after accusations involving the FBI investigation, while the matter is now being referred to the Arizona Attorney General’s Office for further review. What happens next, and could criminal or ethical issues still emerge? Join us live as we analyze the investigations, courtroom strategy, law enforcement politics, and the biggest unanswered questions behind these headline-making cases. 00:00:00 Introduction & Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos Drama 00:22:40 Alex Murdaugh Trial Twist & Becky Hill Misconduct 00:31:02 NYC Serial Killer Harvey Marceline Sentenced Again 00:44:01 Tarrant County Texas Missing Child Investigation 00:54:45 NYPD Behind-the-Badge Story Time & Homicide Course Memories 01:02:50 Outro & Upcoming True Crime Livestreams #AlexMurdaugh #HarveyMarcelin #SheriffNanos #TrueCrime #RollCall #MichaelAlcazar #TrueCrimeCommunity #CrimeNews #NYPD #MurdaughTrial #SerialKillers #Arizona #FBI #BreakingNews #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #joegiacalone

Why are people buying and selling items connected to a serial killer that haven’t even been sentenced yet? And where is the line between true crime interest and exploitation? On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, co-host Josh Zeman joins us alongside special guest Andy Kahan from Crime Stoppers of Houston for an in-depth discussion on the disturbing world of “Murderabilia” and the growing marketplace surrounding accused serial killer Rex Heuermann. As Heuermann awaits sentencing in the Long Island Serial Killer case, collectibles, artwork, letters, and other items connected to infamous killers continue to surface online for profit. Should this be legal? Who benefits? And what impact does it have on victims’ families still searching for justice and closure? Andy Kahan, one of the nation’s leading victim advocates, breaks down the ethics, legality, and emotional consequences of Murderabilia, while Josh Zeman brings insight from years covering the Long Island Serial Killer investigation. We also discuss: * The rise of serial killer memorabilia markets * The psychology behind fascination with killers * Victims’ rights versus free speech arguments * How families of victims are affected * The latest developments involving Rex Heuermann * Whether laws should ban profiting from notorious crimes If you follow the Long Island Serial Killer case, true crime ethics, or the darker side of criminal culture, this is an episode you do not want to miss. 00:00 Introduction of Guest Andy Kahan 01:05 Defining the Murderabilia Industry 02:45 The Emotional Impact on Victims’ Families 04:55 Researching Dealers and Purchasing Items 06:15 Son of Sam Laws and the First Amendment 11:30 Notoriety for Profit Laws Explained 12:45 Selling Items Before a Conviction 15:15 Rex Heuermann’s Hunting Outfit and Vault for Sale 19:10 How Dealers Acquire Personal Items 21:40 Monitoring Inmate Mail and Communication 23:05 Dirt for Sale from Gilgo Beach 25:40 Capitalism versus Morality in True Crime 28:15 Remembering the Victims over the Killers 31:45 The Ethics of the True Crime Genre 34:05 Maintaining a Relationship with David Berkowitz 38:40 Items from the Toolbox Killers and Ed Kemper 42:00 Loopholes in Social Media and Online Sales 45:15 Public Outrage and Removing Listings 52:15 Best Practices for True Crime Content Creators 55:35 Legal Sales and Restitution for Families 58:30 The Resurgence of Cold Case Media 01:00:15 Closing Remarks and Happy Mother’s Day #truecrimewiththesarge #truecrimepodcast #truecrimecommunity #joegiacalone #joshzeman #murderabilia #andykahan #victimadvocate #rexheuermann #LISK