#lisk #longislandserialkiller #rexheuermann A major development in the Long Island Serial Killer case could be just days away. Reports indicate that Rex Heuermann is expected to plead guilty on April 8, 2026, in connection with the murders of seven women. In this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD Sergeant Joseph Giacalone is joined by filmmaker and investigative director Josh Zeman to break down what this potential plea means for the case, the victims, and the unanswered questions that have haunted the Gilgo Beach investigation for over a decade. In addition, Bob Motta of the Defense Diaries podcast will joins us to discuss the legal aspects of a guilty plea. Zeman, known for co-creating The Killing Season, brings insider perspective on the Long Island Serial Killer case, the evidence, and the broader implications for law enforcement and true crime investigations. In this episode: • What a guilty plea from Heuermann could reveal • Why now? Timing behind the reported plea • Will all victims finally get justice? • The role of media and documentaries in shaping the case • What still doesn’t add up in the LISK investigation This is one of the most significant developments in the Long Island Serial Killer case in years. Don’t miss this critical breakdown. 00:00:00 Intro: Breaking down the Rex Heuermann guilty plea rumors 00:01:06 Plea Deal vs. Change of Plea: The critical legal distinction 00:03:51 Is a deal actually on the table? Analyzing Ray Tierney’s stance 00:06:41 The "Statement of Allocution": Will Rex have to provide details? 00:10:33 Will evidence (photos/findings) be released to the public after a plea? 00:13:21 The Molineux Hearing: Uncharged crimes and "prior bad acts" 00:14:45 Post-conviction rights: Can he still appeal for "ineffective counsel"? 00:20:00 The "Why Now?" Theory: Psychological factors and family protection 00:24:45 The RH Planning Document: Discussing the "H&K" torture details 00:31:18 Potential leaks: Information Rex might want to keep hidden from prison 00:34:58 DNA and CODIS: How a New York conviction affects other jurisdictions 00:41:30 Interstate Justice: Can other states extradite him for death penalty cases? 00:46:57 The "Incomplete Story": Unanswered questions regarding other victims 01:02:00 The Mystery of the Storage Lockers: Will we ever know what was inside? #truecrimewiththesarge #coldcase #coldcasefiles #coldcaseinvestigation #truecrimepodcast #truecrimecommunity #truecrimestories #gilgobeach #joshzeman #joegiacalone #josephgiacalone

#nancyguthrie #barbarawaldman #annemaedemegillo In this gripping episode of True Crime with the Sarge, host Joseph Giacalone is joined by retired NYPD Detective Dave Sarni for a no-nonsense breakdown of three major true crime stories making headlines. Next, we dive into the long-awaited breakthrough in the 1974 Long Island cold case of Barbara Waldman. How was this decades-old mystery finally solved, and what role did modern forensic techniques play? We’ll discuss the DNA behind Othram. Finally, we analyze the shocking case of Anne Mae Demegillo, accused in the death of a child in Palm Coast, Florida. What do we know so far, and how will this case unfold in the justice system? This episode delivers expert insight into cold cases, investigative missteps, and high-profile arrests, giving you the inside perspective only seasoned law enforcement professionals can provide. #truecrimewiththesarge #truecrime #truecrimepodcast #coldcase #longisland #nassaucounty #othram

#coldcase #forensicgenealogy #coldcasefiles How are decades-old cold cases finally being solved? In this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, retired law enforcement officer and forensic genetic genealogist Christine Burke takes you inside one of the most powerful investigative tools in modern policing: forensic genetic genealogy. We break down exactly what forensic genetic genealogy is, how it works, and why it has become a game-changer in solving some of the most difficult unsolved cases. From identifying unknown suspects to giving names back to victims, this cutting-edge science is rewriting the rules of criminal investigations. Christine Burke also shares how to become a forensic genetic genealogist, what skills are required, and what aspiring investigators need to know to enter this rapidly growing field. Whether you’re a true crime fan, investigator, or someone interested in the intersection of DNA, genealogy, and justice, this episode delivers real insight into how science is closing cases once thought unsolvable. Topics Covered: • What is forensic genetic genealogy? • How DNA databases help solve cold cases • Real-world impact on unsolved homicides and unidentified remains • The step-by-step investigative process • How to become a forensic genetic genealogist • Ethical and legal considerations in genetic investigations Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge for expert insights, real cases, and behind-the-scenes perspectives from law enforcement professionals. 00:00 – Introduction: The Power of Forensic Genetic Genealogy 03:15 – Guest Introduction: Christine Burke’s Background in Forensics 07:42 – Defining Forensic Genetic Genealogy (FGG) vs. Traditional DNA Testing 12:30 – The Step-by-Step Process of Building a Family Tree 18:15 – Identifying Unknown Remains: The Doe Cases 24:50 – Ethical Considerations and Privacy in Genetic Investigations 31:10 – Overcoming "The Wall": When the Paper Trail Goes Cold 38:45 – Case Study: A Recent Cold Case Success Story 45:20 – The Future of Investigative Genetic Genealogy (IGG) 52:10 – Audience Q&A: Legal Hurdles and Law Enforcement Collaboration 56:30 – Closing Remarks and Upcoming Episodes #truecrimewiththesarge #truecrimepodcast #truecrimecommunity #joegiacalone #christineburke #forensicinvestigativegeneticgeneaology #genealogy #dna #unsolvedmysteries #forensicscience

#kouririchins #nancyguthrie #truecrimestories On this episode of Roll Call on True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar joins us to break down the conviction of Kouri Richins—from the initial investigation to the critical evidence that led to a guilty verdict. We take you inside the case: How did investigators build it? What mistakes were avoided—or made? And what lessons can law enforcement and the public take from this shocking outcome? Then we shift to a developing and controversial issue: Why has it gone so quiet in Pima County regarding the Nancy Guthrie investigation? Is it strategy, silence, or something more? We examine what’s known, what’s not, and what could be happening behind the scenes. This is a must-watch for anyone interested in true crime investigations, courtroom strategy, and the realities of modern policing. Topics Covered: • Kouri Richins conviction breakdown • Investigative timeline and key evidence • Prosecutorial strategy and case building • Detective insights from Michael Alcazar • Nancy Guthrie investigation updates • Why silence from Pima County matters 00:00:00 - Introduction and Guest Michael Alcazar 00:01:32 - Three Scenarios: Is the Guthrie Case Chugging Along? 00:04:31 - Investigation Missteps: Crime Scene Management 00:06:35 - The 40-Day Warning: Sheriff Nanos Criticized 00:08:18 - Why Police Chiefs Should Avoid the Microphone 00:14:13 - The DNA Waiting Game: Mixed Samples and Genealogy 00:16:38 - Federal Involvement: Prosecutors at the Crime Scene 00:20:41 - The Media and the Crime Scene "Trampling" 00:28:00 - The "Burglary Gone Bad" Theory Revisited 00:31:47 - The Recall Effort vs. Vote of No Confidence 00:35:45 - The Sheriff's Corvette and "Insufferable Ego" 00:40:46 - Kouri Richins Convicted: A Case Built Brick by Brick 00:43:57 - The Digital Trail: Google Searches and ChatGPT in Crimes 00:47:02 - Rex Heuermann Update: The "Weinstein Tactic"? 00:52:45 - Story Time: "Get a Homicide Detective" #truecrimewiththesarge #truecrimepodcast #joegiacalone #missingpersons #coldcase #michaelalcazar #crime

#missingpersons #police #investigations On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, host Joseph Giacalone sits down with missing-persons researcher Lorna Ferguson, PhD of the University of Regina, to discuss the science behind missing persons investigations and her groundbreaking book Missing Persons: Beyond Serial Killers and Unexplained Disappearances. While media coverage often focuses on serial killers and mysterious disappearances, Dr. Ferguson’s research reveals a much more complex reality. In this conversation, we explore who actually goes missing, the most common causes of disappearances, investigative strategies used by law enforcement, and why many missing persons cases are misunderstood by the public and the media. We also discuss the categories of missing persons, repeat missing individuals, risk assessment models used by police, and the critical role of data, research, and investigative strategy in finding missing people. If you are interested in missing persons investigations, criminology research, cold cases, and real investigative techniques used by law enforcement, this is a must-watch episode. Topics covered in this episode: • The real statistics behind missing persons cases • Why most disappearances are not linked to serial killers • The different categories of missing persons investigations • How police assess risk in missing persons cases • Repeat missing persons and vulnerable populations • What the public and media often misunderstand about disappearances • The future of missing persons research and investigations This episode is essential viewing for true crime fans, criminology students, law enforcement professionals, journalists, and families impacted by missing persons cases. 00:00 - 01:17 Introductions to the Reality of Missing Persons Cases 01:18 - 04:35 A Personal Connection: The story of “Jess” 04:36 - 07:30 How Media Frames Missing Persons Cases 07:31 - 09:06 International Trend for Vulnerable Populations 09:07 - 11:34 Prevention Strategies and Building Rapport 11:35 - 13:34 How Communities Can Empower Themselves 13:35 - 15:25 The Role of Schools and Social Connection 15:26 - 18:27 Beyond Serial Killers 18:28 - 22:00 Categories of Disappearances 22:01 - 24:41 Jurisdictional Challenges in Missing Persons Cases 24:42 - 25:58 Identifying Issues of Police Response 25:59 - 29:20 Debunking the 48 Hour Waiting Rule in Missing Persons Cases 29:21 - 33:31 Legal Limits 33:32 - 36:49 Risk Assessment & Resource Allocation 36:50 - 40:23 The Lack of Specialized Missing Persons Training 40:24 - 43:55 The Role of Social Services 43:56 - 48:53 Connecting Families and Law Enforcement 48:54 - 51:00 Social Media: A Double-Edged Sword 51:01 - 52:36 How to Get Involved #truecrimewiththesarge #truecrimepodcast #truecrimecommunity #coldcases #missingpersonscases #missing #drlornaferguson #lornaferguson #joegiacalone #unsolvedmysteries #truecrime

#truecrimewiththesarge #rexheuermann #nancyguthrie What strategies will the defense use in the case against alleged Long Island Serial Killer Rex Heuermann? And what investigative lessons emerge from the mysterious death of Nancy Guthrie? On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD sergeant Joseph Giacalone hosts an in-depth discussion with former prosecutor and legal analyst Josh Ritter of Courtroom Confidential and filmmaker Josh Zeman, the writer and director of the investigative true crime series The Killing Season. Together they break down the latest defense motions and legal strategy in the Heuermann case, exploring how defense attorneys challenge forensic evidence, investigative procedures, and digital proof in high-profile serial murder prosecutions. They also examine the science and investigative techniques behind the Nancy Guthrie case, including how timeline reconstruction, forensic evidence, and investigative persistence helped bring clarity to a complex homicide. In this episode: 🔎 Defense tactics and legal motions in the Rex Heuermann case ⚖️ How prosecutors and defense attorneys battle over forensic evidence 🧠 Investigative strategy behind the Nancy Guthrie case 📂 Lessons from real serial killer investigations 🎥 The role of true crime storytelling in exposing investigative details If you’re interested in serial killer investigations, criminal law strategy, forensic evidence, and the realities of solving complex homicide cases, this episode provides expert insight from both the courtroom and the investigative side. 00:00 Welcome & Introduction to the "Triple J" Show 01:14 Josh Zeman’s Observations from the Courtroom 05:32 Breaking Down the 180-Page Omnibus Motion 06:12 Legal Strategy: Challenging Mitochondrial DNA Science 08:58 The "Mountain of Evidence" Beyond DNA 12:59 Why Rex Heuermann is Unlikely to Accept a Plea Deal 16:15 Seeking a Mistrial: The Defense’s "Hail Mary" Hopes 18:32 Trial Strategy: Chronological vs. Investigative Flow 20:52 Probatitve Value vs. Inflaming the Jury (Graphic Evidence) 25:34 The Likelihood of a Hung Jury in Serial Killer Cases 28:48 Alternative Suspects: The "Andrew" & "John Bittrolff" Arguments 33:25 Discussing Past Corruption: Burke and Spata’s Influence 34:56 Serial Killer Trophies: The Significance of "Mementos" 36:59 The Eyewitness: Dave Schaller and the "Ogre" Description 41:55 How the Chevy Avalanche Clue Was Lost for 10 Years 45:51 The Nancy Guthrie Case: Major Police Missteps 51:39 The TMZ "Kidnapping" Notes & Media Circus 54:18 The Geography of Tucson: Why the Search is Difficult 58:01 Potential Federal Takeover of the Guthrie Investigation 01:00:18 Final Thoughts: Comparing Heuermann and Guthrie Timelines #defensemotions #lisk #gilgobeach #longislandserialkiller #nancyguthriecase #joshzeman #joshritter #courtroomstrategy #courtroomconfidential #coldcases #homicideinvestigation

#serialkillers #truecrime #forensicpsychology On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, former NYPD Sergeant and cold case investigator Joseph Giacalone sits down with forensic psychologist and attorney Dr. Susan Lewis to break down the psychology, typologies, and behavioral patterns of serial killers. Dr. Lewis explains how investigators and behavioral experts classify serial killers, including organized vs. disorganized offenders, mission-oriented killers, power-control killers, hedonistic killers, and visionary killers. We also explore the psychological traits, motivations, and patterns that law enforcement and profilers analyze when hunting serial offenders. This deep dive into criminal psychology and behavioral profiling examines how serial killers think, how patterns emerge across cases, and why understanding these typologies can help investigators solve crimes and prevent future violence. If you’re interested in true crime analysis, criminal profiling, forensic psychology, and serial killer investigations, this episode provides expert insight into the science behind some of the most disturbing offenders in history. Subscribe for more true crime investigations, cold case analysis, and expert interviews on True Crime with the Sarge. Topics Covered • Serial killer typologies explained • Organized vs disorganized offenders • Power-control, mission-oriented, and hedonistic killers • Behavioral profiling in homicide investigations • Psychological traits of serial offenders • How investigators identify serial crime patterns 00:00 – 00:29 Introduction: Meet Dr. Susan Lewis, Forensic Psychologist & Lawyer 00:30 – 01:11 What Does a Forensic Psychologist Actually Do? 01:12 – 04:10 The Truth About the "Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity" Defense 04:11 – 06:32 How to Become a Forensic Psychologist 06:33 – 08:37 Defining a Serial Killer: Typologies and the "Cooling Off" Period 08:38 – 09:14 Compartmentalization: How Killers Lead Double Lives 09:15 – 09:59 BTK Case Study: The "Upstanding" Community Member 10:00 – 11:49 Psychopathy vs. Personality: The Hair Psychopathy Checklist 11:50 – 13:23 Ted Bundy: The Master of Superficial Charm 13:24 – 15:50 Inside the Gilgo Beach Case: Corruption and Investigation Failures 15:51 – 20:19 Rex Heuermann’s Souvenirs: Reliving the Crimes 20:20 – 22:49 FBI Profiling: Examining the Childhoods of 36 Serial Killers 22:50 – 24:30 The "Macdonald Triad": Predicting Violent Behavior 24:31 – 31:35 Typologies: Visionary, Mission-Oriented, Hedonistic, and Power/Control 31:36 – 36:35 Were There Warning Signs? Identifying Potential Killers 36:36 – 39:07 Modus Operandi (MO) vs. Signature: Can Killers Change Their Patterns? 39:08 – 45:50 Why Are There Fewer Serial Killers Today? The Impact of Technology 45:51 – 48:17 Jeffrey Dahmer: A Different Psychological Profile 48:18 – 53:14 The Question a Psychologist Would Ask Rex Heuermann 53:15 – 55:33 The Murder Accountability Project: Tracking Homicide Clusters 55:34 – 58:01 The Crisis in Law Enforcement: Clearance Rates and Experience Gaps 58:02 – 58:34 Closing Thoughts and Upcoming Shows #truecrimewiththesarge #truecrimepodcast #truecrimecommunity #typology #criminalpsychology #behavioranalysis #psychology #crimeeducation #crimeshow #mindhunter #joegiacalone #susanlewis

#luigimangione #mickeystines #nickreiner On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, retired NYPD Sergeant and cold case expert Joseph Giacalone sits down with forensic psychiatrist Dr. Carole Lieberman to examine the controversial insanity defense and how it may apply in several high profile criminal cases. Dr. Lieberman analyzes the psychological and legal issues surrounding Luigi Mangione, Sheriff Mickey Stines, and Nick Reiner, exploring whether claims of mental illness reflect genuine psychiatric conditions or legal strategy. Together we break down: 🧠 What the insanity defense really requires in court ⚖️ How forensic psychiatrists evaluate criminal responsibility 🔍 Behavioral patterns prosecutors and defense attorneys look for 📂 Whether these cases show signs of true mental illness 🎙️ How expert testimony can shape a jury’s decision If you follow true crime investigations, criminal psychology, and courtroom strategy, this episode gives you an insider look at how mental health intersects with the justice system. Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge for expert analysis on cold cases, forensic science, criminal investigations, and the biggest cases making headlines. 00:00 - 00:40 - Introducing Dr. Carole Lieberman 00:41 - 01:52 What does a Forensic Psychiatrist do? 01:53 - 02:52 What is the difference between a Forensic Psychiatrist and a Forensic Psychologist? 02:53 - 07:21 Psychological Test in Court 10:48 - 15:23 The McNaughton Rule 15:24 - 24:35 Luigi Mangione Case 25:48 - 33:01 Nick Reiner Case 45:17 - 54:50 Sheriff Mickey Stines Case 54:51 - 1:03:34 Jenny Jones Murder Show Case #truecrimewiththesarge #InsanityDefense #ForensicPsychiatry #CriminalPsychology #truecrimepodcast #justicesystem #DrCaroleLieberman #CriminalInvestigation #courtroomstrategy